Document Type : .
Authors
1 Associate Professor of Sociology, Department of Social Studies, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, Iran
2 Researcher at Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies
Abstract
Introduction
The concept of development and development planning is an issue that has become a problem of the Iranian society in the contemporary era. Therefore, many have studied and criticized this concept, ideas and development plans prepared in Iran. The authors of this research have previously evaluated and investigated the development plans in the second Pahlavi era in a research titled "Construction of Development Plans in Iran before the Islamic Revolution". The present research, which deals with the construction of development plans after the Islamic revolution, in continuation of the same research with the approach of historical sociology and the theoretical model of construction, seeks an answer to how the development plans are formulated after the Islamic revolution.
Materials & Methods
Historical sociology investigates the evolution of social structures and processes, therefore, in a sense, it pays attention to the development of societies and examines the theoretical and practical aspects of the phenomena of human society in a historical context and in a long-term process. This research uses this approach to formulate the planning process. Development in Iran will benefit after the Islamic Revolution. Most of the studies conducted in this field have been limited to one of these aspects or have not examined this phenomenon in a historical context and in a comprehensive process. In terms of the theoretical approach, in this article, the construction theory will be used as an epistemic platform for data processing. The theoretical approach of construction is considered a unified theoretical model and connects two levels of society, micro and macro, so in this approach, social phenomena are created in the interrelationship of structure-actor/agent and are reproduced in a dialectical and dynamic relationship in the historical context of structures.
Discussion & Result
The concept of development, after the Islamic revolution, with the interruption that occurred in its implementation, unlike the experience before the revolution, faced a different worldview, which made the development process face a new problem, and that was the lack of attention to the different foundations of these two phenomena. Therefore, regardless of the coordination of the theoretical basis of these two phenomena, the development process faced serious problems. The effort to align the ideals of the revolution and the theoretical ideas of development was something that was not paid much attention to at first, and this itself became a factor for the internal and external contradictions of this phenomenon. The different approaches of different governments to build the concept of development based on new ideals was another factor that did not help the theoretical construction of this phenomenon. The change of governments in the middle of implementing the programs also prevented the coherence of this phenomenon in the experience after the revolution. In addition to that, the interference of the compiled development plans with the upstream documents made it impossible to construct this phenomenon. This resulted in the formation of an intellectual consensus about the concept and format of development after the revolution and, except for the third program prepared and implemented in the reform government, a coherent thinking environment for development programs was not formed.
In the domain of activists, the development plans after the Islamic revolution faced fundamental challenges. As the conflict between governments and parliaments over the approval and implementation of post-revolution development plans and various government departments with each other, often led to a lack of elite consensus on development plans and even led to non-implementation by governments and their complete negation. As sometimes the development plans have been extended due to these differences and non-approval at the appointed time. Activists of development programs sometimes faced the problem of the possibility of forming this concept by completely denying the planning path in practice.
Conclusion
In the course of history, the developed development plans were faced with events during the implementation phase that made it impossible to form these plans. The most important feature of the development programs after the Islamic revolution, unlike the pre-revolution era, is the budget deficit due to the dependence of the budget on oil and various sanctions since the beginning of the Islamic revolution, which did not provide the possibility of its coherent construction. This has made it impossible to achieve the goals of the development plans and has caused deviations from the plans. Sanctions on Iran and its social, political and economic results have practically made the necessary platform for the implementation and formation of development plans impossible. In other words, for a long time, sanctions have prevented the use of elite capacities, financing, technological supply, etc., and on the other hand, by creating crises and social and economic gaps, it has challenged the development plans. Therefore, the development plans in Iran after the revolution have not been able to be constructed and have remained in the form of ideas and thoughts.
Keywords
- Smith, Dennis (1386), The Rise of Historical Sociology, Translated by Hashem Aghajari, Tehran: Marvarid. [in persian]
- Eftekhari, Ali Asghar (1380), A Sociological Look at The Category of Aristocracy in Two Decades After The Victory Of The Revolution, Islamic Social Research Journal, No. 31, Pp. 44-56. . [in persian]
- Amjad, Mohammad (1384), Comparative Study of Economic Development in Iran and South Korea 1998-1999, Tehran: Islamic Revolution Records Center. . [in persian]
- Amir Ahmadi, Hoshang (1377), Tools of Industrial Development, Continuity and Discontinuity, Translated by Alireza Taib, Tehran: Shiraz Publishing and Research Institute. . [in persian]
- Abrams, Philip (1397), Historical Sociology, Translated by Mansoura Lolavar; Gholamreza Jamshidiha, Tehran: University of Tehran. . [in persian]
- Adamit, Fereydoun (1340), Thought of Freedom and The Introduction of The Constitutional Movement, Tehran: Sokhn. . [in persian]
- Strategic Research Center (1385), Theoretical Pathology of Economic Development Programs, Economic Research Journal, No. 3, Pp. 59-88. . [in persian]
- Aghasizadeh, Fathahullah, Gholaminetaj-Amiri, Saeed (1399), 70 Years of Development Planning in Iran; Damages and Challenges, Tehran: Program and Budget Organization, Development and Foresight Research Center. . [in persian]
- Al-Yasin, Ahmed (1393), History of Development Planning in Iran: (Pathology of Underdevelopment), Tehran: Samar Publishing. . [in persian]
- Babaeifard, Asadullah (1389), Cultural Development and Social Development in Iran, Social Welfare, Volume 10, Number 37, Pp. 56-7.
- Bashirieh, Hossein (1380), Obstacles to Political Development in Iran, Tehran: New Step. . [in persian]
- Beheshti, Mohammad Baqer (1384), Analysis of Policies and Development Programs in Iran, Proceedings of The Conference On Policies and Management of Growth and Development Programs In Iran, Tehran: Higher Institute Of Management And Planning Education And Research
- Parker, John (1386), Construction, Translated by Hossein Ghazian, Tehran: Ney. . [in persian]
- Javadi Yeganeh, Mohammad Reza (1382), Ideological Contradiction in The First and Second Development Programs in Iran, Social Welfare, Number 8, Pp. 120-89. . [in persian]
- Khandozi, Seyyed Ehsan (1389), Evaluation of Development Programming Method in Iran (2009-2008), Planning and Budgeting Journal, No. 110, Pp. 99-128. . [in persian]
- Summary of The Country's Economic Developments in 1369 (1369), Tehran: Central Bank of The Islamic Republic Of Iran. . [in persian]
- Delfrooz, Mohammad Taghi (1393); Government and Economic Development: Political Economy of Development in Iran and Developmentalist Governments; Tehran: Aghah Publishing. . [in persian]
- Razavi, Masoud (1379), Jamia Madani, 2 Khordad, And Khatami: Conversations with Contemporary Iranian Thinkers, Tehran: Farzan Rooz Publishing and Research. . [in persian]
- Rafipour, Framerz (1377), Expansion and Contradiction: An Effort to Analyze The Islamic Revolution And Social Issues Of Iran, Tehran: Sahami Enteshar. . [in persian]
- Zarei, Mojtabi; Rouhani, Alireza (1388), Genealogy and Investigation of The Performance Of The Program And Budget Organization According To The Documents Of The Prime Minister (1326-1343), Tehran: Khane Kitab; Presidential Research And Documents Center. . [in persian]
- Zahedi, Ali (1342), Necessity of Industrial Program, Tehran: Bina.
- - Ziyari, Karamatullah (1381), Program and Planning in Iran, Tehran University Faculty of Literature and Humanities Journal, No. 4, Pp. 618-599. . [in persian]
- - Jobar, Pir Vahede Emeline Prob (1347), Traveling to Armenia and Iran, Translated by Mahmoud Mosaheb, Tehran: Chehar, Franklin. . [in persian]
- - Saree-Ul-Qalam, Mahmoud (1376), Intellect and Development (Fixed Foundations of The Development Paradigm), Tehran: Scientific And Cultural Publications. . [in persian]
- - Sodagar, Mohammad Reza (1369), Growth of Capitalist Relations in Iran (Expansion Stage) 1342-57, Tehran: Sholeh Andishe. . [in persian]
- Saber, Hoda (1397), Single Seeds in Longing for Thread, A Collection of Articles of Fifty Years of Planning in Iran, Compiled by Hoda Saber, Tehran: Parseh. . [in persian]
- Alizad, Ismail (1394), Reflection of Social Development in The Development Programs of The Islamic Republic Of Iran (First To Fifth Programs), Social Sciences Quarterly, No. 70, Pp. 124-159. . [in persian]
- Azimi, Hossein (1383); Circuits of Underdevelopment in Iran's Economy; Tehran: Ney. . [in persian]
- Azimi, Hossein (2019), Iran's Economy: Development, Planning, Politics and Culture (Collection of Articles and Lectures), Edited by: Khosro Noormohammadi, Tehran: Ney. . [in persian]
- Ghaninejad Ahri, Moussi (1377), Civil Society: Freedom, Economy and Politics, Tehran: Tarh-E-No. . [in persian]
- Ghoninejad Ahri, Musa (1396), Economy and Government in Iran: A Research On The Roots And Reasons For The Perpetuation Of The Government Economy In Iran, Tehran: Donyaye Eghtesad. . [in persian]
- Fatahi, Ali (1385), Experience of State Capitalism in Iran, Tehran: Merz Fekar. . [in persian]
- Fayudat, Ebrahim (1374), Industrial Expansion and Its Obstacles in Iran, Tehran: Chappakhsh. . [in persian]
- The Law of The First Plan Of Economic, Social And Cultural Development Of The Islamic Republic Of Iran, 1372-1368 (1376), Tehran: Planning And Budget Organization. . [in persian]
- The Law of The Sixth Five-Year Plan For Economic, Social And Cultural Development of The Islamic Republic Of Iran And The Law Of Permanent Provisions of The Country's Development Programs (1396), Tehran: Planning And Budget Organization. . [in persian]
- The Law of The Third Program Of Economic, Social And Cultural Development Of The Islamic Republic Of Iran 1379-1383 (1382), Tehran: Management And Planning Organization Of Iran. . [in persian]
- Ghanbari, Ali (1391), Economic Development and The Status of Iran, Tehran: Chalesh. . [in persian]
- Ghanbari, Ali, Sadeghi, Hossein (1386), Iran's Economic Developments, Tehran: Samt. . [in persian]
- Qavam, Seyyed Abdul Ali (1393), Challenges of Political Development, Tehran: Qoms Publishing. . [in persian]
- Katouzian, Mohammad Ali (1391), Iran's Political Economy: From Constitutionalism to The End of The Pahlavi Series, Translated By Mohammad Reza Nafisi, Kambiz Azizi, Tehran: Markaz. . [in persian]
- Kasraei, Mohammad Salar, Asghari, Behzad (1402), Construction of The Development Program in Pahlavi Era Iran, Two Chapters of Iran's Economic History Research, Year 12, Number 2, Pp. 1-29. . [in persian]
- Giddens, Anthony (1395), New Rules of Sociological Method, Translated by Akbar Ahmadi, Tehran: Sociologists. . [in persian]
- Collection of The Fifth Five-Year Development Program of The Islamic Republic Of Iran (1390), Tehran: Higher Institute Of Management And Planning Education And Research. . [in persian]
- Collection of Laws of The Fourth Economic, Social And Cultural Development Program Of The Islamic Republic Of Iran (1383), Tehran: Presidential Research Office. . [in persian]
- Mahmoudkhani, Zahra, Keshishian Sirki, Garineh (1395), A Comparative Study of The Foreign Policy Discourses Of The 10th And 11th Governments And Its Impact On The Security Of The Middle East Region, Foreign Policy Journal, Year 30, Number 2 (Series 118), Pp. 7-35. . [in persian]
- Madani Qahfarkhi, Saeed (1396), The State of Human Development in Iran: Vulnerability and Resilience, Tehran: Parse Book Translation and Publishing Company. . [in persian]
- Research Center (1389), General Evaluation of Development Programs After The Revolution, No. 10299, Tehran: Islamic Council Research Center. . [in persian]
- Massoudnia, Hossein, Ebrahimi, Ali, Moradi, Asadollah (1393), Economic Sanctions; Opportunities and Strategies of The Islamic Republic Of Iran In Securing National Interests, Economic Strategy Magazine, Third Year, Number 11, Pp. 43-78. . [in persian]
- Moslinejad, Abbas (1384), Pathology of Economic Development in Iran; Tehran: Qoms Publishing. . [in persian]
- Momeni, Farshad (1374), Physiology of A Development Program, Tehran: Teacher Education University, Economic Research Institute.
- Momeni, Farshad (1394), Iran's Economy in The Era of Structural Adjustment, Tehran: Naqsh and Negar. . [in persian]
- Naghizadeh, Mohammad (1384), The Basics of Economic Thoughts and The Development of Japan, Continuity and Change, Two Volumes, Tehran: Publishing Company. . [in persian]
- Nobakht, Mohammad Baqer, Gholaminetaj, Saeed, Mirahasni, Zahra (1390), Functions of The Development Model; Strategy Quarterly, Q. 20, No. 61, Pp. 213-231. . [in persian]
- Nili, Masoud (1387), Government and Economic Growth in Iran, Tehran: Ni Publishing. . [in persian]
- Vaezzadeh, Sajdeh, Naqdi, Asadullah, Ayaseh, Ali (1394), Social Sustainability Components in Iran's Development Programs, Iran Social Development Studies, No. 26, Pp. 45-60. . [in persian]
- Vaezi, Hassan (1393); Successes and Failures of Development in Iran, The Role of The 5th To 11th Governments in The Country's Political, Economic, Social and Cultural Development; Tehran: Hermes. . [in persian]
- Planning and Budget Organization (1374), Goals, Basic Policies, Policies and Executive Programs of Economic Sectors in The Second Economic, Social and Cultural Development Program of The Islamic Republic Of Iran 1374-1378, Tehran: Planning And Budget Organization. . [in persian]
- OPEC, (2014), Annual Report 2013.