Document Type : .

Authors

1 Phd student of History, Institute of humanities and cultural studies, Tehran, Iran

2 Associated professor of History, Institute of humanities and cultural studies., Tehran, Iran,

3 Assistant professer of History, Imam Khomeini Research institute, Tehran, Iran,

4 Assistant professer of History, Institute of humanities and cultural studies, Tehran, Iran,

10.30465/sehs.2023.44339.1891

Abstract

The most important part of Iran's economy during the Nasri era was the land economy, because the most important part of the country's per capita income and the government's income were provided from this sector. In this article, land ownership in Lorestan and its changes according to the production methods that dominate the land economy of Lorestan. Nasri means the mode of economic production and capitalist mode of production as well as the conditions of production resulting from them in the land economy of this region have been examined by the method of historical study and an attempt has been made to answer this main question that the conditions of production and what was the ownership of the means of production in the land economy of Lorestan in the Nasrid era in both the mentioned production methods and which exploitation system was the dominant method of product distribution between the owner and the farmer? The results of the research It shows that in this region there were four types of ownership (tribal, private, khalsa and waqfi) in which the predominant method of exploitation was in the case of farm production (shareholding) and this exploitation system is the most important factor in preventing the possibility of The growth and development of production forces has been in the region.

Keywords

Extended abstract

Land ownership and exploitation systems in the Naseri period (the case of Lorestan)

Introduction: The most important system of exploitation is the relations of production, which includes the relationship of ownership (the relationship of people with each other in relation to the means of production and work product), exchange, distribution, consumption and the position of people and groups in the production process. (Soudagar 2536: 52; Nomani 1358: 27) The main issue of this research is to explain and understand the system of exploitation and production relations in the agrarian economy of Lorestan and its changes during the Naseri period, and it seeks to answer this question that in the process of changes What was the land ownership of Lorestan during the Naseri era, the dominant exploitation system in this region, and what was the trend in terms of the development of production forces?

Hypothesis: The relations of farm production with its various forms were the dominant exploitation system in lordly and khalase lands. Due to the inherent characteristics of this system, which made the serfs dependent on the lord or the government, there was no consequence other than handing over an important part of the production to the owners of the land and water for the labor force, and practically the possibility of the development of the production forces in the farm was blocked.

In this research, with the method of historical study, the information and data related to the research problem have been identified and collected from the sources with the tool of logbook, and based on the questions raised, they have been analyzed in a qualitative way with the help of documentary knowledge. In the next step, how and how to explain the forms of ownership in Lorestan and their exploitation systems were investigated and the research hypothesis was put to the test.

The purpose of the research: The main purpose of this research is to review and identify the obstacles to the economic development of Lorestan during the Naseri period, in order to provide the knowledge of the causes of underdevelopment in the region and pave the way for development in the province.

Background of the research: A lot of research has been done on the topic of this research at the macro level. For example: the book "Owner and Farmer in Iran" written by Lambton (1362) "The Serf Lordship System in Iran" by Mohammad Soudagar (2016) the book "Land Issue and Class War in Iran" written by Baqer Momeni (1359) the book "The Lordship System in Iran" "Absent in Iran" written by Hamid Abdullahian (1392), "Economic History of Iran" by Charles Essavi (1362) and "The Lost Century" written by Ahmad Syif (1378) are among these researches. From the recent researches in the west of the country: Hamid Abdullahian and Sarveh Fattahi (1391) in the article "Comparative analysis of the land exploitation system in Kurdistan and the group exploitation system..." Shayan Karami and Dariush Rahmanian in "Land Ownership in Kermanshah" First Pahlavi period), Shiva Mohammadi and Mazhar Adway (1399) have discussed this issue in the article "Investigation and explanation of the mutual relations between stewards and owners of Kurdistan in the Qajar and first Pahlavi periods..." We have used the general achievements of these researchers in this research, but in none of the above researches, there is a sufficient discussion about the exploitation system, especially the production relations of Lorestan during the Naseri era, therefore, it is necessary to conduct a new study, which is included in the article. Efforts have been made in this field. Therefore, the innovation of this research is that it specifically deals with the issue of production relations and its effect on underdevelopment in the region.

Findings: The most important exploitation system of land ownership in Lorestan was the farmstead. In the local documents of Lorestan, the existence of farm production relations is repeatedly mentioned: in 1312 AH, according to the farm contract between Asad Khan Valizadeh (owner) and Agha Hossein Zare, the water product of Jabagh located in Khorram Abad was divided between the lord and the serfs in the form of half share. It meant that 50% of the produce belonged to the owner and the other 50% belonged to the farmer, however, the serf was required to pay sarjeft (items such as oil, firewood, and goats) to the owner as well. (Kamam, wali-zadeh family documents) among the subjects of Papi region in Lorestan, especially in the subsistence production method, if the owner's land was rainfed, it was cultivated by assigning the three factors of production (labor, seeds and cattle) to the serfs. During the harvest, the crop was divided into ten parts, two tenths (one fifth) went to the Khan and eight tenths (four fifths) went to the farmer; There was another method of farming to divide the harvest between the parties in this area, which was called "bur", which the lord's steward assessed fifteen days before harvesting, one third in the water crop and one third in the crop. He used to separate one-fifth of the tax for the benefit of the lord. Another model of farming was "charik-dari", according to which the owner, by hiring an agricultural worker for four factors of production in irrigated properties, and in irrigated properties, by removing the water factor, gives him the other three factors to cultivate; At the time of harvest, the farmer's share was a quarter of the crop. (Izadpanah 1376: 122/1) in Silakhor and Borujerd regions, the distribution of crops (rainfed and irrigated) was based on the three-kot model. (Interview with Jamshid Khosravi 1400/9/5) In addition to the lordly properties, there are farms in the Khalsa lands of Lorestan. It was also customary in the Khalesejat region of Jaidar (an area in present-day Poldokhtar) that the irrigated crop was divided into three plots and the rainfed crop was divided into four plots. However, three parts of the rain crop were the right of the serfs and one part belonged to the court. We have mentioned Sarjeft as one of these unfair practices. Leasing, parceling, and hired labor were other exploitation systems in Lorestan, which included a smaller scale than the farm.

Conclusion: Farming with its various forms was the dominant exploitation system in Lorestan during the Naseri era, in which, due to reasons such as the loss of a large share of the surplus in favor of the owner and other non-productive people, and giving part of it as a tax, it was possible for direct labor to progress. Work was not available.

Key words: land ownership, Lorestan, Naseri period, exploitation system, production factors

References
Adamiyat, Fereydoun (1354), "Thought of Social Democracy in Iran's Constitutional Movement", Tehran: Payam.[ In persian]
Ahmadi, Babak (1391), "Marx's Philosophical Dictionary", Tehran: Markaz. [ In persian]
Ahmadi Tabatabai, Ali Mohammad (1384), "Political and social history of Borujerd", edited by Mojtab Moghadasi and Gholamreza Azizi, Tehran: Horufiyeh. [ In persian]
Ezkia, Mostafa (1361), "Sociology of Rural Development", Polycopy Course, Tehran: Faculty of Social Sciences and Cooperation. [ In persian]
Stanford, Mychael (1393), "Income on History Research", translated by Masoud Sadeghi, Tehran: Samt. [ In persian]
Ashraf, Ahmad and Ali Banu Azizi (1386), "Social Classes, Government and Revolution in Iran", translated by Sohaila Torabi Farsani, Tehran: Nilofar. [ In persian]
Etemad ul-Saltaneh, Mohammad Hasan Khan (1368), "Merat ul-Boldan", vol. 4, by Abdul Hossein Navaei and Mirhashem Mohaddeth, Tehran: University of Tehran. [ In persian]
Afshar, Hasan Ali Khan (1382), "Traveller of Lorestan and Khuzestan", edited and researched by Hamidreza Dalvand, Tehran: Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies. [ In persian]
Aman Elahi Baharond, Sekander (1367), "Nomadism in Iran", Tehran: Agah. [ In persian]
Izad Panah, Hamid (1376), "Archaeological and Historical Artifacts of Lorestan",  vol.1., Tehran: Association of Cultural Heritage and Artifacts. [ In persian]
Bahrami, Taqi (1330), History of Iranian Agriculture, Tehran: University of Tehran. [ In persian]
Bahrami, Ruhollah (1388), "Dynasty of Governors of Lorestan", Tehran: Horufiyeh. [ In persian]
Papi Balagriveh, Murad Hossein (1396), Khanjan, Qom: Darul Neshar Islam. [ In persian]
Tagavi, Nematullah (1381), "Rural Sociology", Tehran: Payam Noor University. [ In persian]
Geography of Lorestan (1395), "Pishkoh and Pushtkoh", by Sekander Aman Elahi Baharond, Khorram Abad: Shapourkhast. [ In persian]
Jamal Zadeh, Mohammad Ali (1335), "Ganj Shaygan or Iran's Economic Situation", Berlin: Kaviani Publishing House. [ In persian]
Khosravi, Khosro (2535), "Research in rural society", Tehran: Payam. [ In persian]
Dalmani, Henry Rene (1378), "From Khorasan to Bakhtiari", translated by Gholamreza Samii, vol.2 and 1, Tehran: Tavus. [ In persian]
Dalvand, Hamid Reza (1385), "History of the Islamic Revolution in Lorestan", Vol 1, Tehran: Islamic Revolution Documentation Center. [ In persian]
Dalvand, Hamid Reza (1388), "History and Architecture of Shapurkhast Fort", Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural Heritage of Handicrafts and Tourism. [ In persian]
Dobod, Clement Augustus (1388), "Traveller of Lorestan and Khuzestan", translated by Mohammad Hossein Aria, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural. [ In persian]
Rawlinson, Sir Henry (1398), "Rawlinson's travel book", translated by Sekander Aman Elahi Baharond, Tehran: Agah.
Razmara, Ali (1320), "Military Geography of Iran (Lorestan)", Tehran: General Headquarters of the Army. [ In persian]
Sultanzadeh, Avatis (No Date), "Historical documents of the labor/social democracy and communist movement of Iran", with the efforts of Khosro Shakeri and others, Tehran: Padzahar. [ In persian]
Samiei, Azizullah (1382), Encyclopaedia of Men and Rulers of Kamereh and Japelaq, Vol. 1, Arak: Navay Danesh. [ In persian]
Soudagar, Mohammad (2536), "The Serf Lord System in Iran", Tehran: Golshan. [ In persian]
Sayf, Ahmad (1373), Iran's economy in the 19th century, Tehran: Cheshme. [ In persian]
Seyf, Ahmad (1387), "The Lost Century" (Economy and Society of Iran in the 19th Century), Tehran: Ney. [ In persian]
Shakeri, Khosrow (1384), Social-Economic Backgrounds of Constitutionalism Movement and Development of Social Democracy, Tehran: Akhtaran. [ In persian]
Shamim, Ali Asghar (1389), "Iran during the Qajar Dynasty", Tehran: Behzad. [ In persian]
Sabouri, Manouchehr (1379), Sociology of Organizations, Tehran: Shabtab. [ In persian]
Safinejad, Javad (2536), Bonehs documents, Vol. 1, Tehran: Institute of Social Studies and Research. [ In persian]
Zel oul-Sultan, Masoud Mirza (1363), "History of Masoudi's story", lithography, Tehran: Yasavoli Farhang. [ In persian]
Abdullahiyan, Hamid (1392), "The system of absent lords in Iran", translated by Gholamreza Jamshidiha and Alireza Sadeghi, Tehran: Sociologists. [ In persian]
Abdullahiyan,  Hamid and Sarveh Fatahi (1391), "Comparative analysis of land exploitation system in Kurdistan and group exploitation system (Boneh) in the period before the land reforms", Rural Researches, third year. Number 1, Spring. [ In persian]
Abdollah Yef, Fathullah (1361), "Iranian villagers in the late Qajar period", translated by Marina Kazem, a collection of essays on land and peasant issues, Tehran: Agah. [ In persian]
Charles, Essavi (1362), "Economic History of Iran Qajar Era (1332-1215 A.H.)", translated by Yaqub Azhand, Tehran: Gostareh. [ In persian]
Fashahi, Mohammad Reza (1360), "Development of Capitalism in Iran" (1796-1905 AD), Tehran: Gutenberg. [ In persian]
Floor, Willem (1399), "Agriculture in Iran during the Qajar Period", translated by Shahram Gholami, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural. [ In persian]
Foran, Jan (1390), "Fragile Resistance (History of Iran's Social Developments"), translated by Ahmad Tadayon, Tehran: Rasa Cultural Services Institute. [ In persian]Ghasemi, Farid (1378), "Lorestan Agents", Lorestan Book, Vol 1, by Farid Ghasemi, Tehran: Horufiyeh.[ In persian]
Curzon N. George (1373), "Iran and the Iranian Case", translated by Gholam Ali Vahid Mazandarani, vol. 2, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural. [ In persian]
Karami, Shayan and Dariush Rahmanian (1398), "Private ownership in Kermanshah (1st Pahlavi)", Journal of Local History of Iran, 8th year, 1st issue, 15 consecutively, Autumn and winter. [ In persian]
Kasravi, Ahmad (1390), "Constitutional History of Iran", Tehran: Negah. [ In persian]
Kuzentesva, N.A. and others (1386), "Studies on the modern history of Iran", translated by Siros Izadi and Mitra Izadi, Tehran: Zovar. [ In persian]
Cohen, Alvin Stanford (1381), "Revolutionary Theories", translated by Alireza Tayeb, Tehran: Qoms. [ In persian]
Garthwaite, Jen Raf (1373), "Social Political History of Bakhtiari", translated by Mehrab Amiri, Tehran: Sahand. [ In persian]
Lestrange, Gay (1377), "Historical Geography of Eastern Caliphate Lands", translated by Mahmoud Irfan, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural. [ In persian]
Lambton, A. K. S. (1362), "Owner and Farmer", translated by Manouchehr Amiri, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural. [ In persian]
Najm oul-Dawleh (1386), the second travelogue of Najm oul-Dawleh to Khuzestan, edited and revised by Ahmad Ketabi, Tehran: Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies. [ In persian]
Nomani, Farhad (1358), Evolution of Feudalism in Iran, Vol. 1, Tehran: Kharazmi. [ In persian]
Noshirvani, Vahid (1361), "The beginning of the commercialization of agriculture in Iran", a collection of essays on agrarian and peasant issues, Tehran: Agah. [ In persian]
Niki Tin, P. (1401), Basics of Political Economy, translated by Nasser Zarafshan, Tehran: Agah. [ In persian]
Majd, Mohammad Ali (1400), Fatn oul-Saltaneh's letter, corrected and edited by Sasan Walizadeh, Khorramabad: Havir. [ In persian]
Mahmoud Mirza Qajar (1400), "Traveller of Maqsood Jahan", corrected and annotated by Yadullah Sotoudeh and Mohammad Mohammadi Asl, Khorramabad: Shapurkhast. [ In persian]
Mohammadi, Shiva and Mazhar Advay (1399), "Investigating and explaining the mutual relations between subjects, stewards and owners of Kurdistan during the Qajar and Pahlavi period using the documents of the Waziri family", two quarterly social history research journals, 10th year. , number two, autumn and winter. [ In persian]
Malkam, Sarjan (1380), complete history of Iran, vol. 2, translated by Ismail Hyrat, edited by Mohammad Qominezad, by Ali Asghar Abdolahi, Tehran: Afsun. [ In persian]
Momeni, Baqer (1359), Land issue and class war in Iran, Tehran: Payvand. [ In persian]
Momeni, Qodratullah (1387), history of justice and registration of documents and properties (with a look at the events of the Qajar and Pahlavi eras in Iran and Lorestan), Khorramabad: Shapoorkhast. [ In persian]
Minwerski, Vladimir (1378), "Lorestan in the Encyclopedia of Islam", translated by Zarvan Lorestani, book Lorestan, vol. 1, by Farid Ghasemi, Tehran: Horufiyeh. [ In persian]
walizadeh Moujezi, Mohammad Reza (1380), History of Lorestan during the Qajar era, edited by Hamidreza Dalvand, Tehran: Horufiyeh. [ In persian]
walizadeh Moujezi, Mohammad Reza (1389), The name bearers of Lorestan, edited by Mojtaba Moghadasi, Tehran: Horufiyeh. [ In persian]
walizadeh Moujezi, Mohammad Reza (1396), history of Eilat and clans of Lorestan, with the efforts of Hossein Valizadeh, Khorramabad: ordibehesht Janan. [ In persian]
Wali, Abbas (1375), "Contradictions of the Asian production method", translated by Parviz Sedaqat, Political and Economic Information, No. 111-112. [ In persian]
Wali, Abbas (1380), Iran before capitalism, translated by Hasan Shamsavari, Tehran: Markaz. [ In persian]
Yari, Siavash and Shayan Karami (1399), "The role of economic factors in the settlement of nomads in western Iran (1320-1300)", two quarterly journals of social and economic history research journal, 9th year, 2nd issue, autumn and winter. [ In persian]
Documents of the Ministry and Pishkari of Mirza Seyyed Reza Khan Tafreshi and his children (1400), vol. 1 and 2, by Yadullah Sotoudeh, Khorramabad: Shapurkhast. [ In persian]
Property documents of Jalal Dalvand, Lorestan, Zagheh. [ In persian]
Kammam, (Museum Library and Documents Center of the Islamic Council), documents of the walizadeh family, carton number 457. [ In persian]
Sakma, (National Library and Archives Organization), Document No.: 296-4622, 296-000545. [ In persian]
Institute of Contemporary History Studies, document number: M 12-768-1045. [ In persian]
Vaqai al-Etafakieh, 29 Rajab 1270, number 169. [ In persian]
Vaqai-al-Etafakieh, 7 Ramadan 1271, number 225. [ In persian]
Farhang Isfahan, 19 Safar 1298, number 82. [ In persian]
Farhang Isfahan, 26 Safar 1298, number 83. [ In persian]
Interview with Mr. Jamshid Khosravi, Lorestan, Borujerd, 1400/5/9[ In persian]
Interview with Mr. Mirhossein Dalvand, Lorestan, Zagheh, 1400/10/8[ In persian]
Interview with Mr. Qodratullah Yarahamdi, Lorestan, Khorramabad, 1401/3/7[ In persian]